book review · books · Shar

Review: Foolish Hearts

Hey Virtually readers! I know Shanti already reviewed this, but I’m very tired and running out of reviews, so find out what I thought about Foolish Hearts here.


Title: Foolish Hearts

Author: Emma Mills

Genre: YA Contemporary

Themes: Friendship, theatre

My blurb: Claudia’s about to start senior year, but she’s already got her life figured out. Study hard, under the radar at her private girl’s school, with people she likes but no true friends. Go home and play her favourite RPG with her brother and best friend at home. Repeat.

But when she’s somehow signed up to work on her school’s production of  AMidsummer Night’s Dream, Claudia’s forced to interact with her schoolmates on a deeper level than before. And as the family and friendship’s she’s always relied on change, she might need to learn that her world is worth expanding.

Blurbs can’t really do justice to this book, because it’s so character-focused. While on the outside it had all the elements of just another YA contemporary, it’s one that was so well written and compelling that it was bigger than its borders and made me want to read it in one day.

There were lots of big reasons I liked this, but here’s some small ones: Girls. Playing RPGs. I really liked the RPG aspect of it, just because it was cool and unusual.// Cross-school friendships//Older siblings, like married ones (not something that’s ever happened to me but!!)//A Midsummer Nights Dream+ being a crew member//People who don’t like parties//Bus trips, not clichéd road trips//Boy-band fandom

Like I said, though, Foolish Hearts is mostly about the characters. While it was basically a romance, I liked how friendship and family were such major themes.

Claudia starts the book with one best friend and nothing else. I loved her growth to realise that there were in fact people worth spending time with at school, and the way her friendship with Zoe evolves as she makes space for the new people in her life (and realises that Zoe also has friends other than herself. Like. Wut.). Her friendship with Iris, who at the beginning of the book isn’t very likeable, was so, so richly written and complex, you know? Emma Mills clearly gets friendship.

I also liked the focus on family. Claudia is actually friends with her brother, which was nice; I feel like there’s often an annoying-younger-brother trope in contemporary novels, or occasionally a cool-older-brother one, but instead a friendly, dorky brother was really great. And I liked how she had a way older sister, equally geeky. I think big age gaps in siblings are uncommon in YA books, but less uncommon in real life (I have a 9 year age gap with my youngest sibling, for example), and it was nice to see that written about.

And the romance. Let’s just say this was one of those books that made me really want an awesome, adorkable boyfriend. (I am currently lacking in this department, which is fine seeing as I’m 18 and still lock myself inside cupboards, but still… XD) Gideon was such a great character, round and interesting and leaving me with unrealistic expectations. I very much shipped the ship.

This book had plenty of tropes: school plays, parties, and kisses (not enough. never enough). But at its heart was amazing writing and great characters. I really reallyliked it.

Plot: 4/5

Characters: 6/5

Setting: 3/5

Themes: 4/5

Total: 4.5/5

What have you been reading recently? How tired are you on a scale of 1-10? Do you like musicals or theatre productions?

7 thoughts on “Review: Foolish Hearts

  1. I don’t often read contemporaries but I have this weird Emma Mills exception wherein there’s a certain thing about her books that I can’t explain but really like? I think it’s the “bigger than it’s borders” thing that you mentioned, or the family & friends thing? I like how her characters all very clearly have a life outside of the main character… I’m really glad to hear this one is a good read, I’m really looking forward to reading this one!


  2. Oooh I need to read this! I mean, I say that for so many books but I actually OWN THIS so I have no reason not to devour it soon. 😂I really agree about the sibling age gaps too?! Like my oldest sister is 12 years older than me! (Although there are siblings in between us.) And sometimes that ends up being a bit like having another parent lol lol. Anyway I am tired on a scale of 10 😂 always (thanks insomnia) and I just finished Iron Gold (which I hated 😭) and I’m rereading The Raven Boys because I need something good omg.


  3. I’m beyond the tired scale….. but that’s life now I think!

    I’m glad you and Shanti both enjoyed this one so much! I remember Shanti talking about it when I first met up with you guys. It’s already on my tbr but I’ve been doing barely any reading lately so I don’t know when I’ll get to it… Uni life is too hectic for me to get much reading done. It’s a sad time!


  4. I wanted to read this book for a little while now – I enjoyed Emma Mills’ First and Then a lot and am really looking forward to reading more from her. I love that there’s a great emphasis on family in her stories and that relationship between the MC and her dorky brother, well I’m ALL for that haha 🙂 I can’t wait to read it 🙂 Lovely review! x


  5. I absolutely adored this book as well. I feel like Emma Mills’ books don’t get the attention they deserve, sadly. Her characters and the friendships/family dynamics she writes are always so amazing. Great review!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s